[1IP-107] Aqua LP Incentive Program — Season 2

Simple Summary

Requests a new allocation of 250,000 aETHUSDC from the DAO Treasury for a 13-week Season 2 of Aqua maker incentives on 20 Ethereum pairs. The 1inch Foundation contributes a further $250k in 1INCH, for a total Season 2 budget of $500k. Rewards are paid in USDC and 1INCH on eligible LP fees. Season 1 safeguards and reporting carry over. This has been written incorporating feedback from Anode.

# Abstract

Season 1 of the Aqua maker incentive program, approved under 1IP-105, ran as a three-month program and ended on 27 October 2026. Rewards were authorized only for 1INCH-paired markets, paid on processed volume. Any undistributed Season 1 budget returns to the DAO Treasury under 1IP-105 and is not used for Season 2.

This proposal funds Season 2 and amends those terms in one governance action. It allocates 250,000 USDC from the DAO Treasury to Season 2, alongside $250k in 1INCH from the 1inch Foundation, under updated terms — a market scope no longer limited to 1INCH-paired markets, a reward basis of eligible LP fees rather than volume, and a new 13-week term starting 10 November 2026 at the earliest (Section 2). Administration, claim rails, safeguards, the unspent-funds rule, and reporting all carry over from Season 1.

# Motivation

Season 1 bootstrapped maker liquidity on 1INCH-paired markets with volume-based rewards. Two lessons shape Season 2.

First, pay where the Treasury earns. Protocol fees activated under the Aqua Launch Framework 1IP-103 are taken as a share of the LP fee on each trade. Paying rewards on eligible LP fees ties every reward dollar directly to the fee base on which the Treasury’s own share accrues — the tightest possible coupling between incentive spend and Treasury revenue, and a stricter standard than volume, since rewards flow only where trades actually pay fees.

Second, go where the flow is. The 20 selected Ethereum pairs together carry roughly 76% of Ethereum DEX volume. Restricting incentives to 1INCH-paired markets directed depth toward markets that takers rarely route; Season 2 puts maker depth on the routes where 1inch aggregation flow already executes, so incentivized liquidity competes for real order flow from day one.

# Specification

1. Amendments to 1IP-105

• Market scope. Season 1: curated set of 1INCH-paired markets across networks. Season 2: 20 Ethereum pairs selected by traded share; no 1INCH leg required.

• Reward basis. Season 1: processed volume. Season 2: eligible LP fees (Section 3).

• Term. Season 1: three months from Aqua production launch; ended 27 Oct 2026. Season 2: 13 weekly epochs from the Start Date, 10 Nov 2026 at the earliest (Section 2).

• Budget. Season 1: the 1IP-105 allocation; undistributed funds return to the DAO Treasury at campaign end. Season 2: a new allocation of 250,000 aETHUSDC from the DAO Treasury, transferred to the campaign address through SafeSnap, plus $250k in 1INCH from the 1inch Foundation. Total: $500k.

• Reward tokens. Season 1: 1INCH and USDC. Season 2: USDC (DAO share) and 1INCH (Foundation share), in equal USD halves.

All other 1IP-105 terms — operator, safeguards, exclusion and suspension rights, unspent-funds return at season end, and reporting — remain in force and apply to Season 2 as set out below. The return of undistributed Season 1 funds to the Treasury is unchanged. This proposal changes no protocol fee parameters: LP fee presets and the DAO fee share set under 1IP-103 are untouched.

2. Program parameters

• Start: 10 November 2026 (two weeks after Season 1 ended on 27 October 2026), or the first epoch boundary after the SafeSnap transfer executes, if later (the Start Date). Dates in this proposal assume a 10 November start and move with the Start Date.

• Duration: 13 weekly epochs, to 9 February 2027.

• Budget: $500k in total, split equally across the 13 epochs (about $38.5k per epoch).

◦ DAO: a new allocation of 250,000 aETHUSDC from the DAO Treasury, about 19,231 USDC per epoch.

◦ 1inch Foundation: $250k in 1INCH, about $19.2k per epoch.

◦ DAO spending on Season 2 is capped at 250,000 USDC.

• Chain: Ethereum only.

• Markets: 20 pairs in one reward group (Section 6); pairs do not need a 1INCH leg.

• Reward basis: eligible LP fees (Section 3).

• Distribution: one Merkl campaign; makers claim through Merkl’s standard claim mechanism. Rewards are paid half in USDC and half in 1INCH, by USD value.

3. Eligibility

Rewards are paid on LP fees from all flows on incentivized pairs, except two kinds of trade:

• Self-trade: within one transaction, the same maker’s positions on the same pair trade in opposite directions. Only those legs are excluded.

• Fresh cross-maker trade: within one transaction, different makers’ positions on the same pair trade in opposite directions, and the two positions were created within 1 hour of each other. Both legs are excluded.

Subject to the conditions below, everything else is eligible: order flow (Fusion, aggregator, CoW, UniswapX, limit orders), one-way arbitrage, cross-maker trades between positions created more than 1 hour apart, direct SwapVM fills, and arbitrage between one maker’s positions on different pairs. A position’s creation time is its latest creation (ship) event before the trade.

Conditions. Eligibility is subject to the program terms published at 1inch.com/aqua/incentives and to Merkl’s terms. Rewards accrue only to positions created through strategies that include the access-token gate. Users of a third-party platform are eligible only if the program operator approved that platform in writing before it took part. A trade on which the DAO fee was not collected is not eligible, so every rewarded dollar of fees also paid the Treasury its share.

4. Payout

Every weekly epoch carries the same budget, approximately $38.5k: about 19,231 USDC from the DAO and about $19.2k in 1INCH from the 1inch Foundation. Each epoch’s budget is split pro-rata to each maker’s eligible LP fees across all 20 pairs, and each maker receives USDC and 1INCH in the same proportion. There are no group weights: one dollar of eligible fees earns the same reward on every pair. The budget is set in USD.

5. Performance gates

• Day 30 (approx. 10 Dec 2026): pause if eligible fees in weeks 1–4 average under ~$3,400 per week (8.8% of weekly rewards).

• Day 60 (approx. 9 Jan 2027): continue only if eligible fees in weeks 5–8 average at least ~$6,300 per week (16.4% of weekly rewards).

Fees counted: external LPs’ gross fees (LP fee plus the DAO’s share) on incentivized pairs, with the excluded trades of Section 3 removed. Each gate uses a four-week average, not a single week. The gates are fixed in dollars, so the DAO’s continue-or-stop decision is anchored to absolute fee generation; if the budget changes, the dollar thresholds stay and the percentages move. A paused or ended program returns its remaining budget under Section 9.

A failed gate ends Season 2; it does not resume without a new DAO vote. The program operator posts each gate result, with the four-week figures, on the governance forum within 3 days of the gate date. Gate dates follow the Start Date, and the percentages above assume the full $500k budget: 250,000 USDC from the DAO plus $250k in 1INCH from the 1inch Foundation.

6. Markets — 20 Ethereum pairs

Pair — type — median monthly share:

  1. USDC/USDT — Stablecoin — 31.1%

  2. USDC/WETH — Volatile — 12.1%

  3. USDT/WETH — Volatile — 9.2%

  4. USDS/USDT — Stablecoin — 2.7%

  5. PYUSD/USDC — Stablecoin — 1.8%

  6. stETH/WETH — Correlated — 1.7%

  7. DAI/USDT — Stablecoin — 1.6%

  8. WBTC/WETH — Volatile — 1.6%

  9. USDe/USDT — Stablecoin — 1.6%

  10. weETH/WETH — Correlated — 1.3%

  11. USDT/WBTC — Volatile — 1.3%

  12. wstETH/WETH — Correlated — 1.2%

  13. USDC/USDe — Stablecoin — 1.2%

  14. RLUSD/USDC — Stablecoin — 1.1%

  15. USDC/WBTC — Volatile — 1.0%

  16. DAI/WETH — Volatile — 1.0%

  17. DAI/USDC — Stablecoin — 1.0%

  18. USDC/USDG — Stablecoin — 0.8%

  19. cbBTC/WBTC — Correlated — 0.8%

  20. stETH/USDT — Volatile — 0.14% (added for growth)

The list holds 9 stablecoin, 7 volatile, and 4 correlated pairs (ETH/LST and BTC/BTC), together carrying about 76% of Ethereum DEX volume.

Selection methodology: six 30-day months (15 April – 11 October 2026), Ethereum only. A pair’s monthly score is the average of its share of Ethereum DEX volume and its share of 1inch Ethereum volume. Pairs qualify with a median monthly score of 0.8% or more, at least 0.1% combined share in every one of the six months, and breadth of at least 2,000 DEX traders or 100 1inch users. One exception: stETH/USDT fails the steadiness test but is added because its 1inch volume accelerated in September and no direct DEX pool above $10M serves it; it is reviewed at the day-30 gate.

Season 1 markets not on this list no longer receive rewards. That covers the 1INCH-paired markets, the tokenized-stock, credit, and DeFi-token markets, and every market on chains other than Ethereum.

7. Administration & disbursement

Degensoft continues as program operator, consistent with its administration of Season 1 and of the Foundation-funded base campaigns. On approval, 250,000 USDC is transferred from the DAO Treasury to the dedicated campaign address 0x7c24E3049F46d59114908dB0C3eccd4695f7A8e4 through SafeSnap, after the reality.eth escalation period and the 72-hour Timelock. The 1inch Foundation transfers its 1INCH contribution to the same address before the Start Date. The budget is held only at that address and leaves it only to fund the Merkl campaign or to return to its source; it is never held in the program operator’s own wallets. Degensoft receives no compensation from this budget. Because a delegate submits this proposal, Degensoft Ltd (BVI) confirms in the forum thread, before the temperature check, that it accepts the operator role and its obligations under Sections 7 to 10; those obligations bind Degensoft through that confirmation.

8. Safeguards & abuse monitoring

Season 1’s safeguards carry over: address blacklists (router, resolvers, treasury and team addresses, sanctioned addresses), per-wallet caps, and wash-trading filters, in addition to the trade-level exclusions of Section 3. An on-chain review runs before each weekly payout. Each review separately reports single-maker loops across pairs (for example USDC → WETH → USDT → USDC through one maker’s own positions) and flags any maker whose rewards derive mostly from such loops, as well as makers timing trades around the 1-hour window and clusters of wallets persistently trading with each other. Under the authority carried over from 1IP-105, addresses can be excluded and markets suspended after a review, before payout.

9. Unspent funds

Any budget undistributed at the end of Season 2 — including the remainder after a gate-triggered pause or early end — returns to its source: unspent USDC to the DAO Treasury, and unspent 1INCH to the 1inch Foundation.

10. Reporting

The Season 1 program report remains due on the governance forum within 60 days of Season 1’s end (by late December 2026), per 1IP-105, and will state the exact undistributed balance returned to the Treasury. Degensoft will publish a Season 2 report within 60 days of program end, covering distribution totals, eligible fees generated, gate outcomes, safeguard actions taken, and confirmation of unspent-fund returns to the Treasury and to the 1inch Foundation. Until SwapVM 1.2 (expected around the end of November 2026) makes DAO-fee collection mandatory, skipped DAO fees are tracked and included in weekly monitoring. Trades that skipped the DAO fee are excluded from eligible fees under Section 3.

Before the temperature check, the program operator posts in this thread a short Season 1 results summary: rewards distributed, volume and fees generated, and the balance returned with its transaction hash. Delegates then vote with Season 1 results in hand.

11. Sequencing

No Season 2 rewards accrue for any period before Snapshot approval; the program applies prospectively from activation. Upon approval, the single Merkl campaign is configured for the Start Date (Section 2). If approval lands after 10 November, the start shifts accordingly and the 13-epoch term runs from the actual start date.

# Rationale

Season 2 tightens the flywheel the DAO endorsed in 1IP-93 and funded in 1IP-105. Rewards are paid on the same LP fees from which the Treasury’s protocol-fee share is taken under 1IP-103, so incentive spend tracks Treasury accrual by construction, not by proxy. The market set follows observed flow — 76% of Ethereum DEX volume — rather than a token pairing rule, so incentivized depth competes for order flow that already routes through 1inch aggregation. The dollar-fixed gates put a hard floor under the program: if fee generation does not materialize, at most one month of budget is exposed before the pause, and unspent funds return to their source. The DAO’s commitment is capped at 250,000 USDC, half of the budget; the 1inch Foundation funds the other half in 1INCH.

# Considerations

Security. The program introduces no new smart contracts. It runs as one Merkl campaign on Ethereum against audited Aqua/SwapVM deployments, and reward computation applies the published eligibility rules of Section 3. Protocol fee parameters are unchanged. If SwapVM 1.2 goes live during Season 2, positions on it earn rewards only once its audit report is published.

Legal & risk management. As a Treasury-resource decision, this proposal falls within the risk-review triggers of Guidelines Section 5.6.2, and the review contemplated there is being completed before the temperature check. Rewards compensate makers for eligible fee generation; they are not distributions to tokenholders, and none are proposed. Program parameters, market eligibility, and suspension rights remain under DAO governance and the published campaign configuration.

Conflict of interest. This proposal is submitted by [Anode?], who received no compensation for authoring it. It was developed with technical input from the Degensoft team, disclosed here for transparency. Degensoft Ltd (BVI) is the administrator of this program, the developer of Aqua and SwapVM, and the operator of the official Aqua interface under the Aqua Launch Framework. Mitigants: rewards flow to makers through Merkl’s claim mechanism under the published methodology; Degensoft takes no compensation from this budget; the campaign address is dedicated and published; eligible-fee accrual and payouts are on-chain and independently verifiable; unspent funds return to their source; and Degensoft reports within 60 days of program end.

# Summary

Season 2 puts a new DAO allocation of 250,000 USDC, together with $250k in 1INCH from the 1inch Foundation — a $500k budget — into a 13-week, fee-based maker incentive program on the 20 Ethereum pairs that carry about 76% of Ethereum DEX volume. Rewards are paid pro-rata to eligible LP fees, the same fees on which the Treasury’s protocol share accrues, with wash-resistant exclusions, weekly abuse reviews, dollar-fixed gates at days 30 and 60, and return of anything unspent. The DAO’s capital keeps working where the flywheel actually turns: fees.

Do you support this proposal
  • Yes
  • No
  • Abstain
0 voters
2 Likes

Thanks for writing this Anode! This is very comprehensive and well thought out. We appreciated your clarity on performance gates and look forward to the results covered in section 10’s mentioned reports. Can you share the process for how you arrived at these performance thresholds?

We also noticed that 9/20 pairs are stablecoin pairs, and those generally charge lower fees than something like WBTC/WETH. Since rewards are paid on fees now, what portion of the weekly rewards do you actually expect them to earn? And why did you drop the group weights from Season 1?

Hey @Anode, thanks for posting! I support Season 2. Paying on eligible LP fees instead of volume is the right change (I think I saw the the previous rendition getting gamed by people making massive positions with zero fees). Rewards now track the same fees the Treasury earns on

What I like:

  • Rewards only pay on trades that paid the DAO fee, so the incentive and Treasury revenue line up
  • The day-30 and day-60 gates are fixed in dollars. If fees do not show up, about one month of budget is at risk
  • The 20 pairs follow real flow (~76% of Ethereum DEX volume), not a token pairing rule
  • Unspent funds return to the Treasury

Three questions I have before the temp check:

  • Where are the Season 2 terms? Section 3 points to the program terms at 1inch. I checked 1inch and the Terms of Use. The page still shows Season 1 (volume, 1INCH-paired markets), and neither defines the 1-hour fresh cross-maker rule. Can Degensoft publish the Season 2 terms and the Merkl campaign config, or a draft, before the vote?
  • Approved tokens instead of approved pairs? Any pair between two approved tokens (majors, LSTs, top stablecoins) could earn, with a cap on each pair’s share of an epoch. This catches new routes like stETH/USDT without opening long-tail tokens that are easy to misprice. Season 1 ran on Merkl encompassing campaigns, and a 1inch rewards API computed the rewards. So I think this is feasible and better captures the spirit of this proposal: focusing on revenue generation, through Aqua volumes, for the DAO.
  • Potential risk: Can someone farm the rewards with fake fees? Rewards are ~$38.5k/week, and the day-30 gate only needs ~$3.4k/week of fees. So each fee dollar can potentially earn about $11 of rewards. One person could run a position in one wallet and trade against it from a second wallet. They get most of the fee back as the LP, and they also earn rewards on it. The Section 3 rules only catch this inside one transaction, so two separate trades pass. Fake fees also count toward the gates. Did you consider capping each epoch at a multiple of eligible fees, with the rest returned to the Treasury?

Thanks again for the proposal. I plan on supporting it.


Disclosure: For those who missed it in the delegate thread, I was on the 1inch core team until October 2026. I have no role in this program

Thank you for your questions @FranklinDAO_Penn_Blo Here are some responses:**

  1. How we set the performance gates**

Both gates are measured against Season 1, replayed under Season 2’s rules. We took Season 1’s on-chain trades and removed the trades that Section 3 excludes: self-trades, and cross-maker trades between positions created within 1 hour of each other. Then we summed external LPs’ gross fees (LP fee plus the DAO’s share) on incentivized markets. In Season 1’s first four weeks, that came to about $3.46k a week.

  • Day 30, about $3.4k a week. This is Season 1’s level once wash trades are removed. If Season 2’s first four weeks earn less than that, the new design is not working, and the program pauses. We looked at a lower bar of 5% of rewards (about $1.9k) and rejected it, because Season 2 could clear it without improving on Season 1.
  • Day 60, about $6.3k a week. This is about twice Season 1’s level. It is roughly what fee-weighted payout should deliver if LPs move from quoting about 0.8 bp to about 1.6 bp on the same flow. It asks for growth, not just survival.

As a check, we ran Season 1 through both gates at the Season 2 budget. It would have narrowly passed day 30 (9.0% of rewards) and failed day 60 (7.5%). That is the result we want: Season 1’s fees did not grow, so it would not have continued.

We also re-ran the baseline on the 20 Season 2 pairs, Ethereum only. These pairs had no rewards in Season 1. External LPs on them earned about $300 a week in gross fees in the first four weeks, and about $70 a week in weeks 5 to 8. So the day-30 gate asks for roughly 11 times what these pairs earn without incentives. Season 1’s incentivized markets reached about $3.5k a week, so the bar is reachable, but only if the incentives bring in real flow.

The gates use four-week averages, because LP liquidity takes time to build and single weeks are noisy. They are fixed in dollars, so a smaller budget does not lower the bar.

2. Stablecoin pairs and their share of rewards

Rewards follow fees, so stablecoin pairs have no set share. They earn what their fees earn. A pair quoting 0.5 bp has to fill ten times the volume of a pair quoting 5 bp to earn the same reward.

We estimate the 9 stablecoin pairs will earn about 20–25% of weekly rewards, the 7 volatile pairs about two-thirds, and the 4 correlated pairs about 10–13%. Two measurements agree:

  • In Season 1 these 20 pairs had no rewards. Aqua LPs on them charged about 1 bp on stablecoin pairs and about 5 bp on volatile pairs. Stablecoin pairs carried half of that volume and earned 19% of the fees.
  • Applying the same fee levels to 1inch’s Ethereum flow on these pairs over the last six months, where stablecoins are about 60% of volume, gives 26%.

We kept stablecoin pairs because they are where the flow is. USDC/USDT alone has a median monthly share of 31% in the Section 6 table. Under fee-weighted payout, including them costs nothing unless they produce fees.

Stablecoin pairs are also the cheapest to wash-trade in a loop. The weekly pre-payout reviews in Section 8 report loops through one maker’s positions across pairs, such as USDC → WETH → USDT → USDC. We will watch these pairs closely.

3. Why we dropped group weights

Season 1 paid on volume through eight Merkl campaigns, one per group and chain, each with a fixed budget. Weights were the only way to steer rewards between groups. Each campaign spent its budget whether or not its markets earned fees.

Season 2 is one group on one chain, paid on fees. The fees now do the steering. A pair that earns more fees gets more rewards, so volatile pairs get more without needing a weight.

Adding weights back would pay more per dollar of fees on some pairs than on others. That has two costs. It breaks the one-to-one link between rewards and the fees on which the Treasury’s share accrues. It also tells wash traders where to go: the weighted pairs would pay the most per dollar of fees, so that is where splitting trades across two wallets would pay best.

Season 2 is a clear improvement on Season 1. It pays on fees instead of just volume, targets where flow already routes, and gives the DAO clearer bounds. One of the main aspects that delegates should really be thinking about is long-term goals here and not just strategy isolated to these seasonal campaigns. On that basis, and with longer-term adoption views in mind, we will support the direction of this campaign.

Some more nuanced thoughts:

Ethereum already produced about 90% of Aqua’s 30-day volume, while Season 1’s other chains added little. The 20 selected pairs carry most of Ethereum’s DEX volume and are routes 1inch’s aggregator already trades, so incentivized liquidity can compete for good order flow from day one. Season 1’s 1INCH pairs, by contrast, were markets takers rarely used. And with Season 2 paying on fees rather than volume, concentrating incentives on one chain and one pair list makes the results easier to measure.

Now on the fees:

DefiLlama’s income statement for 1inch Aqua shows the DAO’s fee share across all chains rising from $9.44K in August to $11.14K in September, then holding at $11.49K in October. That’s roughly $2.6K a week, on total swap fees of $51–56K a month. Both lines plateaued after the first full month of Season 1 incentives. Through early November, the DAO has earned about $34.6K from Aqua, on about $175K of total fees.

Season 2 would pay out about $38.5K a week, or roughly $167K a month. That’s about 14.5x the DAO’s Aqua income in its best month, and the full 500K budget is likewise about 14.5x everything the DAO has earned from Aqua to date. At the day-30 bar ($3,400/week of fees), the DAO’s share is about $850 a week, so rewards are about 45x revenue. At day 60 ($6,300/week), they’re about 24x.

For the program to pay for itself, eligible fees would need to reach about $154K a week, or about $667K a month. That’s roughly 12x October’s $54.5K across every chain. This doesn’t rule Season 2 out as a customer-acquisition spend. But “incentive spend tracks Treasury accrual by construction” holds in direction, not really in size, so delegates should remain cognizant of this.


With the Season 1 summary posted ahead of the temp check, as Section 10 commits, we’d be comfortable voting in favor. We look forward to reading the more in-depth retro in December as well. It would be encouraging for the team to supplement the data in the report with ideas around strategy and long-term adoption.

1 Like

Thank you for the feedback @RoundElephant Here is some more information

  1. Terms. The Season 2 terms will be published with the Season 2 marketing campaign, closer to the start. Until then, Sections 3–8 of this proposal define the rules.
  2. Approved tokens. For Season 2 we’ll keep the fixed pair list, to keep the conditions simple for participants. Approved tokens with a per-pair cap is a promising design, and we’ll consider it for future seasons.
  3. Fake fees. Moving to fees changes what wash trading costs and pays, so we expect the patterns to change too. We’ll watch epoch 1 closely and tighten the exclusion rules once we see which patterns are most common. Under Section 8, addresses can be excluded after each weekly review, before payout. Fees excluded that way don’t count toward the gates.
1 Like

Thanks for the detailed review and the support @Arana_Digital
You’re right that Season 2 rewards are well above current DAO income. We see Season 2 as a customer-acquisition spend, not a self-funding program.
We expect the ratio to improve for two reasons:

  • More organic flow. Season 1 paid on volume, so about 95% of it was loops. Season 2 pays on fees and excludes self-trades and fresh cross-maker trades. We expect this to shift rewards toward LPs who fill real order flow, so each reward dollar should buy more real fees. We’ll track this.
  • The DAO pays half. The DAO’s share is $250k. The Foundation funds the other $250k in 1INCH, which halves the DAO’s break-even point.

The downside is capped. If fees miss the day-30 bar, Season 2 pauses. It continues past day 60 only if fees reach $6.3k a week.

Everyone please note that this proposal has been updated. Here is the log of changes

• The DAO is asked for a new allocation of 250,000 aETHUSDC. It is no longer the returned Season 1 balance capped at 500,000 USDC.
• The 1inch Foundation adds $250k in 1INCH. Total budget stays $500k, about $38.5k a week, paid half in USDC and half in 1INCH.
• Season 2 starts on 10 Nov at the earliest or after the vote passes.
• Unspent USDC returns to the Treasury, unspent 1INCH to the Foundation.

1 Like